If you run a Shopify store, you have probably narrowed your email capture options down to two names: Privy and Klaviyo. Both can show popups, both can send emails and SMS, and both have a spin-to-win wheel. So which one should you use?

The short version: they come from opposite directions. Privy started as a popup tool and added email. Klaviyo started as an email and SMS platform and added forms. That origin still shapes what each one does best, and what you pay as your list grows.

This comparison covers popups, gamification, email, pricing and integrations, plus a third option many stores end up choosing: Klaviyo for email, and a dedicated gamified popup app for capture.

Quick answer: Privy or Klaviyo?

Choose Privy if you want one simple tool for popups and basic email on a small list. Choose Klaviyo if email and SMS revenue is your priority and you need deep segmentation and flows. If you want more than a basic spin wheel (scratch cards, slot machines, pick-a-gift games), keep Klaviyo for email and add a gamified popup app that syncs to it.

Table of Contents

Privy vs Klaviyo at a Glance

Privy Klaviyo
Started as Popup and onsite display tool Email and SMS marketing platform
Best for Small stores that want popups + simple email in one place Stores where email/SMS flows drive a big share of revenue
Popup builder Core product: many templates, cart savers, quizzes, exit intent Signup forms: popups, flyouts, embedded forms, multi-step
Spin to win Yes (listed with its Pop-ups & Displays features) Yes, a spin-to-win block in the form editor (2–6 slices, one wheel per form)
Other games Not advertised Not advertised
Email Campaigns and automations, unlimited sends Advanced flows, segmentation, predictive analytics
Free option 15-day free trial, no card required Free plan: up to 250 active profiles and 500 emails/month
Entry paid price $30/month (Email + SMS, up to 1,500 contacts) or $24/month (Displays only) $20/month (Email plan, 500 active profiles)

Prices from privy.com/pricing and klaviyo.com/pricing, checked in November 2026. Both vendors change plans regularly, so confirm before you buy.

Popups and Signup Forms

Privy

Popups are where Privy is strongest. Its display builder includes popups, flyouts, bars, embedded forms and landing pages, along with ecommerce-specific formats like cart savers, cross-sell popups, multi-step popups and quizzes. Exit-intent triggers and A/B testing are part of the package. For a store owner who wants to launch a decent welcome popup in an afternoon, Privy is easy to get going.

Klaviyo

Klaviyo’s signup forms have improved a lot. You can build popups, flyouts, full-page and embedded forms, use multi-step forms (for example email first, then phone number), and target forms by page, device and behavior. The big advantage is that every submission lands directly on a Klaviyo profile, so segmentation and flows start instantly with no sync to worry about.

The trade-off: Privy gives you more onsite formats and templates; Klaviyo gives you a cleaner path from form to email flow.

Spin to Win and Gamification

Both tools now offer a spin-to-win wheel, but neither goes beyond it.

  • Privy lists Spin-to-Win among its Pop-ups & Displays features, next to quizzes and multi-step popups.
  • Klaviyo added a spin-to-win block to its form editor. According to Klaviyo’s help center, each form can have one wheel with 2 to 6 slices, each slice has a whole-number win probability, the wheel must come after an email or SMS consent field, and unique coupon codes require a required email field. Wheel forms can’t use Smart Opt-in or Continue with Shop.

That covers the classic wheel well. What neither tool offers is variety. If your visitors have already seen spin-to-win wheels on dozens of stores, or you want a different game for Christmas or Black Friday, you need a dedicated gamified popup app. SmashPops, for example, includes six games: Spin the Wheel, Scratch Card, Slot Machine, Pick a Gift, Card Dance and Claw Machine.

Gamification is worth getting right. Public benchmarks from popup vendors such as Sleeknote and Claspo put gamified popups at roughly 8% of displays converting, compared with under 4% for standard popups. We break down those numbers in our gamified pop-ups guide.

Email and SMS Marketing

This is where Klaviyo pulls ahead for most growing stores.

Klaviyo is built around customer data: deep Shopify sync, behavior-based segments, predictive metrics, and pre-built flows for welcome series, abandoned cart, browse abandonment, post-purchase and win-back. If email and SMS already produce a meaningful share of your revenue, Klaviyo is hard to beat.

Privy covers the essentials well: campaigns, automations, abandoned cart emails, SMS, and unlimited email sends on every plan. It is a good fit if you want a simple all-in-one setup and don’t need advanced segmentation yet.

If you already use Klaviyo for email, our Shopify Klaviyo integration guide walks through the setup that gets the most out of it.

Pricing: What You Really Pay as Your List Grows

Both tools price by audience size, so the “starting price” is only part of the story.

Privy has two main options:

  • Email + SMS plans, priced by mailable contacts: $30/month up to 1,500 contacts, $45 at 2,000, $90 at 5,000, $165 at 10,000 and $390 at 25,000. Popups are included, along with 250 SMS credits per month.
  • Pop-ups & Displays only, priced by page views: $24/month up to 10,000 views, $48 up to 25,000 and $84 up to 50,000.
Line chart of Privy Email and SMS plan pricing by mailable contacts, from $30 at 1,500 contacts to $390 at 25,000 contacts

Klaviyo has a free plan for up to 250 active profiles and 500 emails a month. The Email plan starts at $20/month for 500 active profiles and 5,000 emails, and the Marketing plan at $25/month. Prices then rise with your number of active profiles; use Klaviyo’s pricing calculator for your exact list size. Signup forms, including the spin-to-win block, are part of the platform rather than a separate product.

The key point: with either tool, your popup cost grows with your list, because the popups come bundled with email. A popup tool priced by number of popups shown, not by contacts, keeps capture costs flat while your list grows.

Which One Should You Choose?

Your situation Best fit
New store, small list, want one simple tool Privy
Email/SMS is (or will be) a major revenue channel Klaviyo
You want lots of onsite formats (cart savers, bars, quizzes) Privy
You need advanced segmentation and flows Klaviyo
You want spin-to-win plus other games (scratch, slot, gift box) Klaviyo + a gamified popup app
Your list is growing fast and capture costs are climbing Klaviyo + a popup app priced by impressions

The Third Option: Klaviyo + a Gamified Popup App

Many Shopify brands end up with this setup: Klaviyo for email and SMS, and a specialised popup app for capture. You get Klaviyo’s flows and segmentation, plus onsite games that a general email platform doesn’t offer.

Here is how it works with SmashPops:

  1. A visitor plays a game (spin the wheel, scratch a card, open a gift box) after entering their email.
  2. SmashPops creates a unique, one-time Shopify discount code for their prize.
  3. The new subscriber is sent to Klaviyo (or Omnisend, Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign, Drip or AWeber).
  4. Your Klaviyo welcome flow takes over and reminds them to use their prize.

SmashPops is priced by popups shown, not contacts: a free plan with 100 popups a month, then $9/month for 5,000, $24 for 20,000 and $49 for 50,000. That means your capture cost doesn’t grow just because your Klaviyo list does. For a step-by-step setup, see our guide to spin to win with Klaviyo and Omnisend.

FAQ

Is Privy better than Klaviyo?

For popups alone, Privy offers more onsite formats and templates. For email and SMS marketing, Klaviyo is more powerful. The right choice depends on whether onsite capture or email automation matters more to your store right now.

Can I use Privy and Klaviyo together?

Yes. Some stores use Privy for popups and Klaviyo for email. Just remember you are then paying two tools that both price by audience size. If you only need Privy for popups, compare it with popup-only tools.

Does Klaviyo have spin to win?

Yes. Klaviyo’s sign-up form editor includes a spin-to-win block with 2 to 6 slices and custom odds. It is limited to one wheel per form and doesn’t offer other game types.

Does Privy have spin to win?

Yes, Privy lists Spin-to-Win among its pop-up and display features.

What is the cheapest way to add spin to win to Shopify?

If you already use Klaviyo, its built-in wheel costs nothing extra. If you want more games or a capture tool that doesn’t scale with your list, a gamified popup app like SmashPops starts with a free plan and paid plans from $9/month.

Keep Klaviyo. Upgrade your popups.

SmashPops adds 6 popup games, unique one-time coupons and smart triggers to your Shopify store, and syncs every signup to Klaviyo. Free plan available.

Try SmashPops free