Privy has been a go-to popup tool for Shopify stores for years. But a lot of merchants start looking for a Privy alternative at the same moment: when the email list grows and the monthly bill grows with it, or when they move their email marketing to Klaviyo or Omnisend and realise they are paying for two email platforms.

This guide compares six alternatives, with their real starting prices, the games they offer and how they connect to your email tool. We included our own app, SmashPops, and we have tried to be fair about where each tool is the better pick.

Quick answer: what is the best Privy alternative?

If you already use Klaviyo or Omnisend, try their built-in signup forms first. If you want gamified popups (spin the wheel, scratch cards, slot machines) at a flat price, SmashPops starts free and costs $9/month for 5,000 popups. For a broad popup builder with surveys and many formats, look at Poptin; for a spin wheel specialist, Wheelio.

Table of Contents

Why Merchants Look for a Privy Alternative

Privy is a solid product. The reasons people switch are usually about fit, not quality:

  • Price grows with your list. Privy’s Email + SMS plan starts at $30/month for up to 1,500 mailable contacts, then climbs: $90 at 5,000 contacts, $165 at 10,000 and $390 at 25,000.
  • You already have an email platform. If Klaviyo or Omnisend sends your emails, you mainly need popups. Privy does offer a Pop-ups & Displays-only plan ($24/month up to 10,000 page views), but you may find cheaper or more specialised options.
  • You want more than one game. Privy offers Spin-to-Win, but if you want scratch cards, slot machines or seasonal games, you need a dedicated gamified popup tool.
Line chart of Privy Email and SMS plan pricing by mailable contacts, from $30 at 1,500 contacts to $390 at 25,000 contacts

Privy Alternatives Compared

Tool Free option Cheapest paid plan Games Best for
SmashPops Free plan (100 popups/month) $9/mo, 5,000 popups Wheel, scratch card, slot machine, pick a gift, card dance, claw machine Gamified popups on Shopify
Klaviyo forms Free plan (250 active profiles) $20/mo Email plan (500 profiles) Spin to win (2–6 slices) Stores already on Klaviyo
Omnisend forms Free plan Scales with contacts Wheel of Fortune (3–20 slices) Stores already on Omnisend
Poptin Free plan (1,000 visitors/month) $19/mo, 5,000 visitors Spin the wheel, scratch card Many popup formats + surveys
Wheelio 7-day trial $14.92/mo, 30,000 impressions Wheel, scratch card, slot machine Spin wheel specialists
OptinMonster No free plan (14-day money-back) Coupon wheel on Growth: $49/mo billed yearly Coupon wheel Multi-platform agencies, big sites

Prices from each vendor’s pricing page or Shopify App Store listing, checked in November 2026.

Bar chart of the cheapest paid plan including a spin-to-win game: SmashPops $9, Wheelio $14.92, Poptin $19, Klaviyo Email $20, Privy Displays $24, Privy Email and SMS $30

1. SmashPops

Best for: Shopify stores that want gamified popups without paying more as their list grows.

SmashPops is a Shopify app built around popup games. Instead of one spin wheel, you get six game templates (Spin the Wheel, Scratch Card, Slot Machine, Pick a Gift, Card Dance and Claw Machine) and 50+ themes. Each winner gets a unique one-time Shopify discount code (percentage, fixed amount, buy X get Y), which stops prizes from leaking to coupon sites.

  • Targeting: exit intent, scroll, number of visits, page, device and country.
  • Integrations: Klaviyo, Omnisend, Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign, Drip, AWeber, Shopify Flow and CSV export.
  • Extras: duplicate and junk email prevention, a coupon reminder bar and analytics.
  • Pricing: free plan with 100 popups/month; $9/month for 5,000; $24 for 20,000; $49 for 50,000. 7-day free trial on paid plans.

Limitations: SmashPops focuses on capture and does not send emails or SMS. You pair it with your email platform. It is Shopify only.

2. Klaviyo Signup Forms

Best for: stores that already send email with Klaviyo.

If Klaviyo is your email platform, its built-in signup forms are the obvious first test. You can build popups, flyouts and embedded forms, use multi-step forms to collect email then phone, and add a spin-to-win block. Every submission lands directly on a Klaviyo profile.

  • Spin to win: one wheel per form, 2 to 6 slices, custom odds. Unique coupons require a required email field.
  • Pricing: free plan up to 250 active profiles and 500 emails/month; Email plan from $20/month for 500 active profiles.

Limitations: one game type only, and your cost scales with your profile count.

3. Omnisend Forms

Best for: stores that already use Omnisend for email and SMS.

Omnisend includes popups, landing pages and a Wheel of Fortune form item on all plans, including its free plan. The wheel supports 3 to 20 slices, and losing slices are decorative only: visitors never land on them. Unique discount codes per spin are available for Shopify stores.

Limitations: like Klaviyo, the wheel is the only game, and the platform price scales with contacts.

4. Poptin

Best for: stores that want many popup formats, including surveys and quizzes.

Poptin is a general popup and form builder with a large template library, spin-the-wheel and scratch card popups, and a long list of integrations (Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Omnisend, HubSpot, ActiveCampaign, Zapier). It has a 4.9-star rating from 347 reviews on the Shopify App Store.

  • Pricing: free plan for 1,000 visitors/month; Growth 500 at $19/month (5,000 visitors); $29/month for 10,000 visitors.

Limitations: priced by visitors, so busy stores move up tiers quickly. Gamification is one feature among many rather than the focus.

5. Wheelio

Best for: stores that mainly want a spin-to-win wheel.

Wheelio is one of the original spin-to-win apps for Shopify, with wheel, scratch card and slot machine formats. It has a 4.7-star rating from 245 reviews and integrates with Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Omnisend, Postscript, PushOwl and SMSBump.

  • Pricing: $14.92/month up to 30,000 impressions; $29.92 up to 60,000; $54.92 up to 100,000; $109.92 up to 250,000. 7-day free trial.

Limitations: no free plan, and fewer game types than a dedicated multi-game app.

6. OptinMonster

Best for: agencies and multi-platform businesses (WordPress, WooCommerce, Shopify and more).

OptinMonster is a powerful, platform-agnostic lead generation tool with advanced targeting and A/B testing. For Shopify stores looking specifically for gamification, note that the Coupon Wheel and Shopify integration are listed on the Growth plan: $49/month billed annually ($588 for the first year), renewing at $1,470/year. Exit intent starts on the Pro plan.

Limitations: annual billing, and the wheel is locked to the top public plan. See our full list of OptinMonster alternatives.

How to Choose the Right Privy Alternative

Ask yourself three questions:

  1. Who sends your emails? If it is Klaviyo or Omnisend, start with their forms, then add a specialised popup app only if you need more.
  2. How do you want to pay? By contacts (Privy, Klaviyo, Omnisend), by visitors (Poptin), or by popups/impressions (SmashPops, Wheelio). If your list is growing fast, a price based on popups shown is usually the most predictable.
  3. How much do you care about gamification? Gamified popups convert at roughly twice the rate of standard popups in public benchmarks (see our gamified pop-ups guide). If games are central to your capture strategy, pick a tool with several of them so you can rotate formats.

If you are still weighing Privy against Klaviyo specifically, read our Privy vs Klaviyo comparison.

FAQ

What is the best free Privy alternative?

Klaviyo and Omnisend both have free plans with signup forms and a spin wheel, which suits stores already on those platforms. SmashPops (100 popups/month) and Poptin (1,000 visitors/month) also have free plans if you want a separate popup tool.

Is there a cheaper alternative to Privy for Shopify?

Yes. Among popup-only tools with a spin-to-win game, SmashPops starts at $9/month, Wheelio at $14.92/month and Poptin at $19/month, compared with $24/month for Privy’s Displays-only plan and $30/month for its Email + SMS plan.

Can I move from Privy without losing my subscribers?

Yes. Export your contacts from Privy as a CSV and import them into your email platform, or make sure Privy already syncs them there. Then switch your popups to the new tool and keep the same welcome flow.

Which Privy alternative has the most popup games?

SmashPops offers six games: Spin the Wheel, Scratch Card, Slot Machine, Pick a Gift, Card Dance and Claw Machine. Wheelio offers three formats, and most email platforms offer only a wheel.

Switching from Privy? Try a popup your visitors want to play.

6 games, unique one-time coupons, Klaviyo and Omnisend sync. Free plan, then from $9/month, whatever the size of your list.

Install SmashPops free